Thoughts and musings, usually on comics but not always, from Russell Burlingame, author of Comic Related's "Conscientious Sequentials" column.
Friday, August 20, 2010
Coming Soon
Tuesday, March 23, 2010
Comics in the Classroom, Camelot and Candidates (of the Rogue Variety)
Some quick notes on things I’ve noticed in the last few days…
First of all, it was called to my attention after I wrote up JMS’ new-to-video release Ninja Assassin yesterday that Straczynski’s bestselling and wildly controversial Spider-Man: One More Day is available for only $6.97 in hardcover in the bargain section of Barnes & Noble bookstores all over the country. Seems like a great chance for continuity junkies who didn’t like the story, but feel like they ought to own something so important, to get it cheap.
There are only 60 days remaining to make yourself part of the upcoming Reading With Pictures Anthology, which is being funded through Kickstarter. It’s 45% funded, with $4,500 of its final $10,000 already pledged. The book involves a bunch of really cool creators working together for a good cause, so I’d say to at least check it out. If somebody else doesn’t contribute in the next month, I’m going to have to raise the level of my contribution. And I’m a cheap bastard, so don’t make me do that!
Speaking of worthy causes on Kickstarter, Ted Rall’s sequel to his great To Afghanistan & Back is still up in the air, with only about half of the total cost donated and a little under two weeks before he’s got to report back to the publisher. Rall’s one of the most fearless and funny graphic novelists in the market right now, so I’d suggest everyone check his work out and think about helping him get funded.
Third and final fundraising shill (for now): Zach Roberts, who masterminded the Greg Palast/Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. comic book Steal Back Your Vote (of which I was an editor–full disclosure here), has a forthcoming documentary about Sarah Palin called Rogue Candidate; it’s not up yet, but he’s been discussing some very interesting and comics-related promotion avenues for the film, so keep your eyes and ears open; it may be the first documentary film ever to have a comics adaptation.
Starz is not only taking some stories from England, but a style of televising them, too; the network has greenlit a Camelot miniseries that will run for ten episodes and be written by Chris Chibnall of Torchwood fame. Removing “Starz” from this sentence, when I first heard that this was happening, I assumed that it was a BBC or BBC America series being reported. It will, however, go nicely with their Spartacus: Blood and Sand series.
Last week at South by Southwest, Warner Brothers announced that they planned on using DC superheroes as tentpole films starting in 2012 or so to replace the departing Harry Potter franchise. There’ll be some overlap, of course, with the last two Harry Potter movies not yet released and Green Lantern already shooting, but it’s a sound business idea on paper, I think, and setting them up as tentpoles unto themselves means that people will have to start thinking of them as viable commercial franchises instead of just talking about how there are all these random superhero movies being made and when will they go out of style. Should be interesting and really fun for comics fans…provided that Warner can make it work.
Thursday, March 18, 2010
Friday, January 29, 2010
“World’s greatest superheroes?” I just don’t see it.
The first issue featuring the newest incarnation of the Justice League of America’s lineup hit this week, and over the top of the title, DC blares that the book features the world’s greatest supeheroes. While no more inherently ridiculous than the Fantastic Four’s long-held claim to being the greatest comic magazine, this one’s a lot more offensive. Why? Because the cover features Congorilla, Mon-El/Valor wearing a Superman logo (everybody’s doing it—the Eradicator, raised from the dead without explanation in this month’s issue of The Outsiders, is back to sporting a big, red S as well) and Starfire, who’s come to this team straight from the orgy of failure that is The Titans. Joined in this comic by fellow Titans (not Teen Titans—Titans. There’s a difference) Donna Troy, Dick Grayson and Cyborg, it soon becomes clear that the Justice League of America has become the dumping-ground for promising characters who just don’t fit into DC’s idea of what they want to do with other titles (like letting a crazed badguy who’s already been overexposed since Identity Crisis lead his own team of “Titans”). Mon-El and The Guardian, both so incredibly popular with the fans that during the time they’ve starred in the Superman titles, sales have dropped by about forty percent, represent the Metropolis contingent with Batman’s understudy and Hal Jordan (currently featured in three monthly books as well as guest-starring all over the place) being the closest thing this team has to A-listers. Seriously, folks, I think that the upcoming Justice League: Generation Lost by Keith Giffen and Judd Winick, which will feature Guy Gardner, Booster Gold, Fire, Ice and the rest of the old JLI—once known as the all-time bottom of the Justice League barrel—may feature a more prestigious lineup than these clowns.
Inside, Red Tornado has been torn to pieces for something like the 185th time in his last 185 appearances. Vixen, the only representative of the Detroit Era JLA to make it into this volume of the title and who has been, to the disappointment of many fans, a member of the team since J’Onn J’Onzz left for no reason after having been with the team since its founding, decides that she’s got to quit the team, because she’s ashamed of what they did at the end of the hideously misguided editorial abortion known as Justice League: Cry For Justice (yes, the end of the miniseries that hasn’t ended yet).
The rest of the team struggles to recover from the aftereffects of Blackest Night (yes, the end of the miniseries that hasn’t ended yet), which raised many of their old teammates from the dead as villains, and even forced some living heroes to play dead for a while so they could be villains. Don’t worry, James Robinson assures the readers, “We ‘awoke,’ though. We survived.” That’s good news, I guess, for the thousands of readers who are eagerly awaiting February 24th’s Blackest Night #7 (of 8), in which the story of those heroes who have been taken over by Nekron continues to play out. I’m sure nobody would mind being told that the biggest event of the year, in which many fans have invested hundreds of bucks following every arcane tie-in, comes out alright enough in the wash.
All of these little editorial gaffes might be forgivable…if the comic were any good. Or original. Or fun. It’s none of those things. Mark Bagley’s art looks rushed and is outright hideous in some places (look at Damien’s face as he declares himself part of the Justice League, or Donna’s as she arrives to invite Batman. Also, if Hal Jordan’s body hasn’t been horribly mangled on a torture rack of some kind by the end of Blackest Night, there’s no reason whatsoever for the length of his torso and legs in comparison the rest of his body on the final story page). The story is dull and something we’ve all seen a hundred times before—Wonder Woman, acting as the only member of DC’s trinity not currently dead or living in outer space, picks a League and the rest of the issue is spent on a recruiting binge. There’s very little in terms of logical, reasonable cause to bring the characters together. Instead, it’s a team that’s being forced together out of the disparate pieces that DC editorial have decided, and Wonder Woman has prescribed, will compose it. It’s a whole issue of going through the motions, and the cardboard dialogue and pedestrian plot has to remind readers of last week’s awesome Starman #81 that James Robinson is best when he’s not handling the icons. Taking a franchise that nobody believed in or cared about, he crafted arguably the best ongoing monthly of the 1990s. Taking control of Superman and the Justice League of America, he’s created a directionless mess filled with uninteresting takes on third-tier characters.
Wednesday, December 23, 2009
Creative Team Changes Imminent for Booster?
Dan Jurgens, who created the character and has drawn virtually every solo Booster story ever told, is currently the writer and artist; he participates in a monthly creator commentary here on Blog@, and also at Comic Related, that looks at Booster Gold shortly after publication. The possibility of Dan’s imminent departure hasn’t come up in any of our interviews, or off-topic e-mail conversations; I can say, though, that in order to replace Jurgens, the team would have to be phenomenal for the book to remain afloat.
Blue and Gold
So, following the revelation at the end of Booster Gold #27, I decided that Booster Gold: Blue and Gold was something that needed to be read through again. I did pick up on a few things that might be worth mentioning, but not worth an actual story, so...BLOG!
First of all, I noticed that there was a lot of items on Rip's blackboard that are, or seem to be, already explained:
- "The Perfect Peter Platinum isn't so perfect" - That guy appeared in Booster Gold #1,000,000
- "Listen to Libra - The Prince will fall on his sword." - J'Onn? Makes sense, given the time of the issue (I think), but why call him "The Prince"?
- "Why, Captain Atom? Why?" Given his role in Countdown, as Monarch, I'm guessing that's what's being referenced here.
- "Jean-Paul Valley Lives," immediately followed by "That's not him" was likely foreshadowing a new Azrael, which we've seen the fruit of already.
- "Trigon = Red herring" was actually the central plot point at the end of Booster Gold #24 and 25 - the last story written before "Blackest Night".
There still hasn't been a story to follow up on Rip Hunter's claim that he knows better than anyone else that you can't save people who are "supposed" to be dead, however badly you want to. It'd be interesting to know what the intent was there, and whether Jurgens still intends to follow up on Katz and Johns's idea. And there also hasn't been a direct follow-up on Jon Carter/Supernova calling Black Beetle "Joshua." While the throwaway line of his being from wherever he wants to go, whoever he wants to be, can pretty much make that irrelevant, it's the only time he's been referred to by a name, and it's by an ally, not an enemy, so he may have less of a reason to lie to Jon.
Friday, May 8, 2009
Flash Facts: Ethan Van Sciver on Flash: Rebirth #2
Van Sciver Talks Designing A New Costume For Wally West
Artist Assures That The Flash: Rebirth #3 Will Be "A Revelation"
Following the events of Final Crisis, Barry Allen is alive and well again…but he’s hardly spent a minute not wearing his Flash suit. Since helping to defeat Darkseid, he’s been wandering the countryside, averting catastrophes and wondering aloud if the world was better without him. In the closing moments of #1, the villainous speedster Savitar emerged literally out of Barry’s chest, but was almost immediately caught by Allen…whose touch turned the self-appointed “speed god” to dust. This issue follows up on the events of that book, and features the death of all the members of Savitar’s speed cult.

There’s a framing device where the action—such as it is, in a book where so little happens that the reader is left to feel like Barry Allen, watching the seconds tick by like hours—of some of the apes in Gorilla City painting a cave mural of Barry Allen, with black lightning bolts reaching out and blasting other speedsters. When asked whether the painting itself might be a clue to one of Geoff Johns’ arcane mysteries, not unlike the chalkboard in Rip Hunter’s lab during the writer’s runs on52 and Booster Gold, artist Ethan Van Sciver said, “I wouldn't look for anything like that. It's fairly direct, and one-dimensional in more ways than one. Then again, maybe Geoff had something else up his sleeve. He always seems to.”
There’s a whole lotta nothin’ goin’ on in The Flash: Rebirth #2 by Geoff Johns and Ethan Van Sciver. The art is absolutely beautiful—some of the best work of the already-very-accomplished Van Sciver’s career—but the whole issue is spent telling what the first issue already showed (a clear violation of one of the cardinal rules of comics and cinematic storytelling). Let’s review:
· Barry Allen, back from the dead after all these years, isn’t as thrilled about it as everyone else is.
· He’s acting very standoffish, making even his closest friends feel a touch awkward around him.
· As a result of his resurrection, crazy things are happening in and around the Speed Force, including but probably not limited to the death of Savitar (seen last issue when Barry touched him as he tried to escape from his prison inside the Speed Force) and the strange “speed seizures” that this provoked in DC’s other speedsters. The fact that the speed seizures were greater for those characters more directly connected to the Speed Force is not surprising, but one of the few new pieces of information given this issue.
· Barry Allen is the new Black Flash.
This last point isn’t necessarily old news (although I think everyone with half a brain had assumed it at the end of issue #1) but it certainly was done in a telling-instead-of-showing way, with Wally actually saying the words to Barry at the end of the issue.
Given that Barry and Wally spend most of the issue talking or running together, the issue of their almost-identical costumes becomes a bit of a bone of contention once or twice, particularly since one of the only weaknesses in Van Sciver’s art is the fact that the two of them have virtually identical faces. “It's a major problem,” the artist confirms, adding, “and will be dealt with in this miniseries. I do my best to always distinguish them from one another, but it's hard sometimes.” He says that “the easiest answer, to alter Wally's costume more drastically from Barry's,” is “part of the gig.” Says Van Sciver, “It's my job to find Wally a new suit that is familiar to fans and different than Barry's.”
We get all of this for our money, plus about ten pages dedicated to the “Nora Allen’s unresolved murder” retcon introduced last issue and the heart-pounding “Secret Origin of Barry Allen’s Bowtie,” which might have been a great story if written tongue-in-cheek but unfortunately was neither. There are also other, quieter retcons in the series as well (continuing the tradition Johns started in Green Lantern: Rebirth when anything that didn’t serve his needs was treated to have simply never occurred) as “I was in witness protection” is apparently a magical phrase that makes the world forget they spent the last however-many-years knowing that you were The Flash.
Ultimately, as much as I love Geoff Johns ordinarily, he’s striking out with this series so far for me. I didn’t need to see Barry back as The Flash before this story started, but at least I wasn’t openly hostile to the notion. I’m getting there. The flawless work by Van Sciver might make this the best case of lipstick on a pig in recent publishing history, but that doesn’t make it inherently worth reading.
According to Van Sciver, though, if you agree with my assessment of the series so far, “Issue #3 will be a revelation for you.”